Содержание

В.В. Поликарпов. Измерения экономического роста России в начале ХХ в. и проблема источников



В.В. Поликарпов. Измерения экономического роста России в начале ХХ в. и проблема источников // Исторический вестник. 2020. Т. ХXХII. С. 10—29.

V.V. Polikarpov. Measurements of Russia’s economic growth in the early 20th century and the problem of sources [Izmereniya ekonomicheskogo rosta Rossii v nachale XX v. i problema istochnikov]. Istoricheskij vestnik / Historical Reporter. Vol. 32. 2020. P. 10—29.


Ключевые слова: Россия, военная промышленность, сравнительно-исторические оценки; эконометрический и микроэкономический методы, Л.Б. Кафенгауз, В.И. Бовыкин, П. Грегори, К.Ф. Шацилло.

Key words: Russian Empire, military industry; comparative historical estimates, econometric and microeconomic methods, L.B. Kafengauz, V.I. Bovykin, P. Gregory, K.F. Shatsillo.



Аннотация

В спорах о том, процветала ли или переживала кризис поздняя Российская империя, историки разделились на «оптимистов» и «пессимистов». При обосновании своей точки зрения обе стороны прибегают к статистическим подсчетам, но особенности хозяйственного быта в России и бедность имеющегося материала источников ограничивают результативность статистических и макроэкономических приемов сравнительного изучения. Наиболее рациональным представляется сочетание квантитативного подхода с анализом описательных источников.

Ключевым направлением исследования, обеспеченным документальной базой, может послужить приоритетная для власти сфера — промышленная и научно-техническая подготовка к войне. Состояние дел в этой области показывает предел возможностей страны и поэтому важно для понимания общих процессов ее развития.

Накопленный историками и экономистами исследовательский опыт заслуживает критического анализа. 


Abstract

While disputing whether the late Russian Empire experienced a crisis or lived in prosperity, historians are either pessimists or optimists. To confirm their point of view they refer to statistic data, but the resulting quality of both statistical and macroeconomic methods is much lowered by the lack of sources and the specifics of economic life in Russia.

The most rational approach could be to combine quantitive methods with analysis of descriptive materials.

Industrial, scientific and technical preparations for war, which was of the top interest for authorities and therefore has a vast documentary base could be the key areas of investigation.

The state of affairs in this area shows the limits and opportunities of the country and therefore this information is essential for understanding the general tendencies of its development.

The cumulative experience of historians and economists should be critically analyzed.



References

  1. Anan’ich B.V. Rossiia i mezhdunarodnyi kapital. Ocherki finansovykh otnoshenii. L., 1970 [Anan’ich B.V. Russia and international capital. Essays on the history of financial relations. Leningrad: Nauka, 1970]. 316 s.

  2. Bokarev Yu.P. Ekonomicheskaia istoriia i ekonomicheskaia teoriia. Nauchnyi doklad [Economic History and Economic Theory. A Scholar paper]. Moscow: Institut ekonomiki RAN. 2007. 52 p.

  3. Bokarev Yu.P. Tempy rosta promyshlennogo proizvodstva v Rossii v kontse XIX — nachale XX v. [The growth rate of industrial production in Russia in the late XIX — early XX century] // Ekonomicheskii zhurnal. 2006. № 11. S. 158–190.

  4. Bokarev Yu.P. Tempy rosta promyshlennogo proizvodstva v Rossii v kontse XIX — nachale XX v. [The growth rate of industrial production in Russia in the late XIX — early XX century] Vyp.13 // Ekonomicheskaia istoriia. Obozrenie. Moscow: Moscow State University Publishers, 2007. S. 170–179.

  5. Bovykin V.I. Dinamika promyshlennogo proizvodstva v Rossii (1896– 1910 gg.) [Dynamics of industrial production in Russia (1896–1910)] // Istoriia SSSR. 1983. № 3. S. 20–52.

  6. Bovykin V.I. Finansovyi kapital v Rossii nakanune Pervoi mirovoi voiny [Financial capital in Russia on the eve of the First World War]. Moscow: ROSSPEN, 2001. 320 s.

  7. Bovykin V.I. Formirovanie finansovogo kapitala v Rossii. Konets XIX v. — 1908 g. [Formation of financial capital in Russia. The end of XIX century — 1908]. Moscow: Nauka, 1984. 287 s.

  8. Bovykin V.I. Kontsentratsiia promyshlennogo proizvodstva v Rossii v kontse XIX — nachale XX v. [Concentration of industrial production in Russia in the late XIX — early XX century] // Istoricheskie zapiski. Vol. 110. Moscow: Nauka, 1984. S. 154–195.

  9. Bukovetskiy A.I. Vvedenie v finansovuiu nauku [Introduction to financial science]. Leningrad: Gosudarstvennoe finansovoe izdatel’stvo SSSR. Leningradskoe otdelenie, 1929. 253 с.

  10. Diakin V.S. Germanskie kapitaly v Rossii. Elektroindustriia i elektricheskii transport [German Capitals in Russia. Electro-industry and electric transport]. Leningrad: Nauka, 1971. 288 s.

  11. Gregory P. Ekonomicheskaia istoriia Rossii: chto my o nei znaem i chego ne znaem. Otsenka ekonomista [Russian economic history: What we know and do not know. An economic appraisal] // Ekonomicheskaia istoriya. Iezhegodnik. 2000. Moscow: ROSSPEN, 2001. S. 7–97.

  12. Gregory P. Ekonomicheskii rost Rossiyskoi imperii (konets XIX — nachalo XX v.). Novye pods’chety i otsenki [Economic growth of the Russian Empire (the end of XIX century — the beginning of the 20th century). New calculations and estimates]. Moscow: ROSSPEN, 2003. 255 s.

  13. Gregory P. Poisk istiny v istoricheskikh dannykh [The search for Truth in historical data] // Ekonomicheskaia istoriia. Iezhegodnik. 1999. Moscow: ROSSPEN, 1999. S. 471–492.

  14. Gregory P. Russian National Income, 1885–1913. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press, 1982. 359 р.

  15. Gudkov L., Dubin B. Nevozmozhnost’ istorii [The impossibility of history] // Vittorio. Mezhdunarodnyi nauchnyi sbornik, posvyashchennyi 75-letiiu Vittorio Strady. [Vittorio. International scholar anthology dedicated to Vittorio Strada’s 75th Birthday] Moscow: Tri kvadrata, 2005. S. 302–355.

  16. Il’in S.V. Promyshlennoie razvitie Rossii ot kontsa XIX v. i do nachala stalinskogo «Velikogo pereloma» [Industrial development of Russia from the end of the XIX century and up to the Stalin «Great Breakthrough»] // Ekonomicheskii zhurnal. 2002. № 5. P. 198–215.

  17. Izmest’ieva T.F. [Vystuplenie pri obsuzhdenii lektsii S.V. Il’ina o promyshlennom razvitii Rossii] [Speech during the discussion of the lecture of S.V. Il’in on the industrial development of Russia] // Konferentsii, diskussii, materialy. 2004. Sb. nauchnykh trudov Kafedry istorii Rossii. [Conferences, discussions, materials. 2004. A Collection of scholar works of The Department of Russian History.] Moscow: RUDN, 2004. S. 149–153.

  18. Jones D.R. Imperial Russia’s Forces at War // Military Effectiveness. Vol. 1. The First World War. New Edition. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press, 2010. P. 249–328.

  19. Kafengauz L.B. Evoliutsiia promyshlennogo proizvodstva Rossii (posledniaia tret’ XIX v. — 30-e gody XX v.) [Evolution of industrial production in Russia (the last third of the nineteenth century — the 30s of the 20th century)]. Moscow: Epifaniya, 1994. 845 s.

  20. Kannegiser I.S. Zadachi protektsionizma v metalloobrabatyvaiuchshei promyshlennosti [The Tasks of Protectionism in Metal-working Industry]. Saint-Petersburg: Luch, 1915. 44 s.

  21. Khvostova K.V. Aktual’nye problemy sovremennoi epistemologii i metodologii istorii [Actual problems of contemporary epistemology and methodology of history] // Dialog so vremenem. [Dialogue with Time] 59. Moscow: IVI RAN, 2017. S. 3–17.

  22. Kirchner W. One Hundred Years. Krupp and Russia. 1818–1918 // Vierteljahrschrift für Sozial- und Wirtschaftsgeschichte. 1982. Band 69. Heft 1. 1. Quartal. S. 75–100.

  23. Konotopov M.V., Smetanin S.I. Razvitie ekonomiki Rossii v XVI–XX vekakh. Izbrannye trudy. V 4-kh tomakh. K 65-letiiu M.V. Konotopa. T. 1. Iz tupika. [The development of economy of Russia in 16th — 20th centuries. Selected works. 4 vols. On M.V. Konotop’s 65th Birthday. Vol. 1. Out of the impasse: Economic experience of the world and the path of Russia.] Saint- Petersburg: Aleteiia, 2018. 374 s.; Vol. 4. Istoriia chernoi metallurgii Rossii; Pravda o proshlom i buduchshem [A History of Russian Metallurgy: Truth on the Past and Future]. Saint-Petersburg: Aleteiia, 2018. 188 s.

  24. Krylov A.N. Vospominaniia i ocherki [Memoirs and essays]. Moscow: USSR Academy of Sciences Publishers, 1956. 884 s.

  25. Markevich A., Harrison M. Pervaia mirovaia voina, Grazhdanskaia voyna i vosstanovlenie: natsional’nyi dokhod Rossii v 1913–1928 gg. [First World War, Civil War and Recovery: Russia’s National Income in 1913–1928]. Moscow: Mysl’, 2013. 109 s.

  26. Marks K., Engels F. Sochineniia [Works]. Vol. 23. Moscow: Gosudarstvennoe izdatel’stvo politicheskoi literatury, 1960. 907 p.

  27. Marks K., Engels F. Sochineniia [Works]. Vol. 24. Moscow: Gosudarstvennoe izdatel’stvo politicheskoi literatury, 1961. 648 p.

  28. Material’no-tekhnicheskoe obespechenie russkoi armii nakanune i v period Pervoi mirovoi voiny. Voienno-teoreticheskii trud [Matèriel and technical support of the Russian army on the eve and during the First World War. Military theoretical study]. Saint-Petersburg: VAMTO, 2015. 348 s.

  29. Ohlin G. No Safety in Numbers: Some Pitfalls of Historical Statistics // Industrialization in Two Systems. Essays in Honor of Alexander Gerschenkron. New York, 1966. P. 68–90.

  30. Ostrovskii A.V. Rossiyskaia derevnia na istoricheskom pereput’e. Konets XIX — nachalo XX v. [Russian village at the historical crossroads. Late XIX — early XX century]. Moscow: Tovarishchestvo nauchnykh izdanii KMK, 2016. 431 s.

  31. Rossiia. 1913 god. Statistiko-dokumental’nyi spravochnik. [Russia. 1913. Statistical and documentary reference book]. Saint-Petersburg: Blits, 1995. 416 s.

  32. Savvin N.N. Russkaia mashinostroitel’naia promyshlennost’ [Russian machine-building industry] // Zapiski Imperatorskogo Russkogo Tekhnicheskogo obshchestva [Papers of Imperial Russian Technical Society]. 1914. № 11. P. 243–246.

  33. Shatsillo K.F. Gosudarstvo i monopolii v voennoi promyshlennosti Rossii. Konets XIX v. — 1914 g. [State and monopolies in military industry of Russia. Late 19th century — 1914]. Moscow: Nauka, 1992. 270 s.

  34. Shatsillo K.F. Russkii imperializm i razvitie flota nakanune Pervoi mirovoi voiny (1906–1914 gg.) [Russian imperialism and the development of the Navy]. Moscow: Nauka, 1968. 397 s.

  35. Shepelev L.E. Tsarizm i burzhuaziia v 1904–1914 gg. Problemy torgovo-promyshlennoi politiki [Tsarism and bourgeoisie in 1904–1914. Problems of trade and industrial policy]. Leningrad: Nauka, 1987. 272 p.

  36. Smetanin S.I. Vtoroi etap industrializatsii Rossii [The Second Stage of Russia’s Industrialization] // Ekonomicheskaia istoriia Rossii XIX–XX vv. Sovremennyi vzgliad [Economical history of Russia of XIX–XX centuries. Modern view]. M.: ROSSPEN, 2001. S. 279–282.

  37. Thérу Ed. Rossiia v 1914 g. Ekonomicheskii obzor [Russia in 1914. Economic review]. Paris: IMCA-PRESS, 1986. 158 s.

  38. Thérу Ed. Ekonomicheskoie preobrazovanie Rossii [Economic review]. Moscow: ROSSPEN, 2008. 183 p.

  39. Voronkova S.V. Otsenka dinamiki promyshlennogo potentsiala Rossii v 1913–1920-kh gg. (nekotorye metodologicheskie i istochnikovedcheskie aspekty temy) [Estimation of the dynamics of industrial potential of Russia in 1913–1920s. (some methodological and source-research aspects of the topic)] // Industrializatsiia v Rossii. Informatsionnyi biulleten’ nauchnogo seminara [Industrialization in Russia. Information bulletin of the Scholar Seminar]. 1998. № 5. S. 5–22.

  40. Voronkova S.V. O materialakh obsuzhdeniia i postupivshikh otzyvakh na lektsiiu S.V. Il’ina [On materials of discussion of S.V. Il’in’s lecture and delivered comments] // Konferentsii, diskussii, materialy. 2004. Sb. nauchnykh trudov Kafedry istorii Rossii [Conferences, discussions, materials. 2004. A Collection of scholar works of The Department of Russian History]. Moscow: RUDN, 2004. S. 165–167.

  41. Zagrebin S.S. Kul’turnaia politika Rossiiskogo gosudarstva v kontse XIX — pervoi treti XX v. [Cultural policy of the Russian state in late 19th — the first third of the 20th century]. Cheliabinsk: Abris, 2006. 376 s.


Поликарпов Владимир Васильевич — кандидат исторических наук член Бюро Секции «История социальных реформ, движений и революций» Научного совета РАН по фундаментальным вопросам российской и зарубежной истории.

Vladimir V. Polikarpov — Candidate of Historical Sciences, Member of the Section «History of Social Reforms, Movements and Revolutions» of the Scientific Council of the Russian Academy Sciences on the Fundamental Issues of Russian and Foreign History.




Номер журнала, к которому относится содержание