В.В. Хутарев-Гарнишевский Проблема происхождения и подлинности дневника великого князя Михаила Александровича за 1915–1918 гг. Источниковедческая штудия

В.В. Хутарев-Гарнишевский Проблема происхождения и подлинности дневника великого князя Михаила Александровича за 1915–1918 гг. Источниковедческая штудия

Аннотация

При изучении дневников великого князя Михаила Александровича были обнаружены многочисленные правки и приписки, сделанные отличным от авторского почерком. Содержание некоторых дописок носит тенденциозный политический характер. Запись о дне отречения 2 марта 1917 г., предположительно, была искусственно сокращена. Статья представляет собой источниковедческое исследование и посвящена проблеме подлинности дневников великого князя Михаила Александровича. Был проведен текстологический и историко-сравнительный анализ, привлечены материалы графологической экспертизы

Ключевые слова: Михаил Александрович Романов, Государственный архив РФ, источниковедение, Коллекция Форбса, фальсификация исторических источников, Февральская революция

Владимир Владимирович Хутарев-Гарнишевский – Кандидат исторических наук, доцент кафедры истории и философии Московского государственного института культуры. Москва, Российская Федерация.

SPIN-code: 5785-9890

AuthorID: 964528

***

Vladimir V. Hutarev-Garnishevsky The Problem of Origin and Authenticity of the Diary of Grand Duke Mikhail Alexandrovich for 1915–1918

Abstract

Studying the diaries of Grand Duke Mikhail Alexandrovich discovered numerous edits and additions in handwriting different from that of the author. The content of some of the additions is of a tendentious political nature. The entry about the day of abdication on March 2, 1917, was presumably artificially shortened. The article is a source study and is devoted to the problem of the authenticity of the diaries of Grand Duke Mikhail Alexandrovich. Textual and historical-comparative analysis was carried out, and materials of graphological examination were involved.

Keywords:  Michael Alexandrovich Romanov, State Archive of the Russian Federation, Source studies, Forbes Collection, falsification of historical sources, February Revolution

Vladimir V. Hutarev-Garnishevsky – C.Sc. (History), Associate Professor at the Moscow State Institute of Culture. Моscow, Russian Federation.

SPIN-code: 5785-9890

AuthorID: 964528

***

References

1. Davidov M.I., Pereskokov L.V., Nikonova O.E. Medical history of Grand Duke Mikhail Alexandrovich Romanov. Annals of Surgery. 2019;24(6):443–449.
2. Diary and correspondence of Grand Duke Mikhail Alexandrovich, 1915–1918; Resp. ed. and comp. by V.M. Khrustalev. Moscow: PROSAiK; 2012. 797 p.
3. Erofeeva G.I. The documentary legacy of Grand Duke Mikhail Alexandrovich in foreign archives. Bulletin of the Bryansk State University. Historical sciences. 2024;(2):61–78.
4. Crawford R., Crawford D. Mikhail and Natalia. Life and love; Transl. from English by A. Mikoyan. Moscow: Zakharov; 2008. P. 586.
5. Lavrenova A.M., Sofʼina M.V., Sofʼin D.M. The diaries of Grand Duke Mikhail Alexandrovich: Features of their form and content. Voprosy Istorii. 2023;12(2):91–92.
6. Moshansky A.B. The abduction of Mikhail Romanov. About the causes and circumstances of the abduction and murder of citizens Mikhail Alexandrovich Romanov and Nikolai Nikolaevich Johnson in Perm. Perm: Kungur printing house; 2022. P. 40.
7. Khrustalev V.M., Lykova L.A. The sorrowful path of Mikhail Romanov: From the throne to Golgotha. Documents, investigation materials, diaries, memoirs. Perm: Pushka; 1996. P. 93–104.
8. Khrustalev V.M. Diary of Grand Duke Mikhail Alexandrovich for 1918 and his correspondence correspondents during his stay in Perm. URL: https://www.permgaspi.ru/deyatelnost/doklady-romanovskie-chteniya-2024-2/istoriya-imperatorskogo-doma-romanovyh-k-410-letiyu-doma-romanovyh-i-300-letiyu-goroda-permi/hrustalev-v-m-dnevnik-velikogo-knyazya-mihaila-aleksandrovicha-za-1918-g-i-ego-korrespondenty-po-perepiske-v-period-nahozhdeniya-v-permi.html?ysclid=m5qo18qdal167405614.
9. Khutarev-Garnishevskiy V.V., Putyatin I.E. The abdication and the last days of Grand Duke Mikhail Alexandrovich in the memoirs of Princess Olga Putyatina. Historical Reporter. 2019;27:230–274.